- Daniel Errante
- Jeep Wrangler Enthusiast
When it comes to rugged off-road prowess, few vehicles have stood the test of time like the Jeep Wrangler and the Toyota 4Runner. Both are iconic in their own right, with loyal followings and legendary reputations. But when you’re considering a new off-road companion, which one deserves the space in your garage? We’re digging deep to compare these two titans of the trail to help you decide which should be your next adventure vehicle.
Heritage and Design
The Jeep Wrangler is the spiritual descendant of the Willys Jeep used in World War II. Its design speaks to its utilitarian roots, with a boxy frame, round headlights, and a seven-slot grille that is unmistakably Jeep. Despite modern updates, the Wrangler has maintained its classic look, much to the delight of Jeep enthusiasts. The body-on-frame design and solid axles are old-school, but they contribute to the Wrangler’s outstanding off-road abilities.
The 4Runner comes from a different tradition, one rooted in the 1980s rise of the sport utility vehicle (SUV). It blends truck-like utility with the comfort of a passenger car. While the 4Runner’s design has evolved, it has also stayed true to its origins, maintaining a rugged, boxy look that signals its adventure-ready capabilities. The 4Runner, too, boasts a body-on-frame construction, reflecting its serious off-road intentions.
Jeep’s reputation for off-road capability is well-earned, and the Wrangler is the brand’s crown jewel. Every Wrangler is Trail Rated, meaning it’s designed to perform in a variety of challenging off-road conditions. It offers exceptional ground clearance, impressive approach and departure angles, and some versions come with front and rear locking differentials, and a sway bar disconnect system for maximum wheel articulation. In short, the Wrangler is at home in the mud, rocks, or crossing streams.
The 4Runner is no slouch off the pavement either. It features impressive ground clearance and off-road technology, such as a locking rear differential and Toyota’s Multi-Terrain Select and Crawl Control systems on certain trims. The 4Runner is more than capable of tackling demanding trails, and for many, it represents the perfect balance of off-road talent and everyday usability.
Interior Comfort and Technology
The modern Wrangler is far more civilized than its ancestors, but it’s still a utilitarian at heart. That said, buyers can choose from a spartan base model to a plush, fully-loaded option with features like leather seats, a touchscreen infotainment system with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, and automatic climate control. What’s unique about the Wrangler is its removable doors and roof, which can transform it into an open-air off-road machine.
The 4Runner leans more toward comfort and convenience, with a spacious interior that’s designed for long drives and off-road adventures. It offers a higher level of standard equipment, and its infotainment system includes Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. The 4Runner also features more cargo space, and for those who need to transport more passengers, there’s an optional third row, making it a versatile choice for families.
Performance and Efficiency
Under the hood, the Wrangler offers several engine options, including a turbocharged four-cylinder, a V6, a diesel, and even a plug-in hybrid. Transmission options include both manual and automatic. The Wrangler isn’t known for great fuel efficiency, especially with the larger, heavier models, but performance, particularly with the torquey diesel or the quick turbo-four, is reliable.
The 4Runner keeps things simple with a single powertrain: a 4.0-liter V6 engine coupled with a five-speed automatic transmission. Some might find this pairing outdated, especially compared to the variety offered by the Wrangler, but there’s no denying its reliability. The 4Runner’s fuel economy isn’t going to win any awards either, but its engine provides enough power for both on- and off-road situations.
Safety and Reliability
Jeeps, with their removable tops and doors, historically haven’t been the stars of safety ratings. However, the current Wrangler has taken steps to improve, with a host of available modern safety features, including blind-spot monitoring, rear cross-traffic alert, and forward collision warning. On the reliability front, the Wrangler is solid, but it can suffer from the rattles and squeaks that often accompany off-road-oriented vehicles.
Toyota is renowned for its vehicles’ reliability, and the 4Runner lives up to that pedigree. With fewer high-tech gadgets and a tried-and-true powertrain, there’s less that can go wrong. When it comes to safety, the 4Runner includes the Toyota Safety Sense package as standard, offering a suite of advanced features like automatic emergency braking and adaptive cruise control.
Price and Value
The Wrangler and 4Runner both hold their value exceptionally well, and while neither is particularly inexpensive, they offer good value for the off-road enthusiast. The Wrangler starts at a lower price point, but fully kitted out models can easily surpass the 4Runner’s higher base price. It’s worth noting the cost of ownership over time as well, with potential for higher maintenance costs on the Jeep due to its off-road focus.
Choosing between the Jeep Wrangler and the Toyota 4Runner comes down to what kind of off-road experience you’re looking for and what factors matter most to you. If you want an iconic, hardcore off-road vehicle with the ability to go topless and doorless, the Wrangler is unparalleled. However, if you seek a more family-friendly SUV that still can hold its own on the trails, the 4Runner could be the better option.
Ultimately, both SUVs embody the spirit of adventure and are highly capable in their own right. Whether climbing over boulders or cruising down the highway, these two will get you where you want to go, with fun and flair to spare. So gear up, hit the trails, and embrace the great outdoors in whichever ride you choose.